Coping with Disaster

Most of Medical personnel during an emergency or disaster event often blinded by all the wounds and injuries and overlook the one essential part of being healthy; mental health well being. Disaster Mental Health is always being considered as the collateral damage of the disaster situation because of its nature of invisibility. Even though stress reactions immediately following a traumatic event are very common and most of the reactions will resolve within few days, it also can cause severe and long lasting reaction to trauma if the victim doesn’t cope well after the disaster crisis ends.

An event, or series of events, that causes moderate to severe stress reactions, is called a traumatic event. Traumatic event can potentially affecting those who suffer injuries or loss and can also reverberate in survivors, rescue workers, friends and relatives of victims who have been directly involved. In addition to those directly involved in the disaster, stress reaction can affect even with those not directly affected by the disaster such as those who have witnessed the event either firsthand or on television. Different people will react to traumatic event differently and highly depend on their ways of coping mechanism. Some victims even will feel that their world turns upside down after experiencing disastrous traumatic event.

As a health professional, our main objective of managing this problem is to provide general strategies for promoting mental health and resilience in disaster victims. We need to always keep in mind that it takes time for those victims to start feel better, so we need to be patient in handling these patient. We are also encouraged to referring those affected to the disaster event as survivors instead of victims. The psychological first aid is used in communicating with traumatic victims that basically encompasses of active listening and empathy. We can also try to advise them to stay busy and follow their normal routines as much as possible whilst limit their time around the sights and sounds of what happened and don’t dwell on TV, radio, or newspaper reports on the tragedy. it will only haunt their memory. Lastly, as cherry on top, eat healthy meat by carefully not to skip meal or to overeat and exercise to stay active.

Some people are at greater risk than others for developing sustained and long-term reactions to a traumatic event including disorders such as post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), depression, and generalized anxiety. Factors that contribute to the risk of long-term impairment such as PTSD are listed.

• Proximity to the event. Closer exposure to actual event leads to greater risk (dose-response phenomenon).
• Multiple stressors. More stress or an accumulation of stressors may create more difficulty.
• History of trauma.Meaning of the event in relation to past stressors. A traumatic event may activate unresolved fears or frightening memories.
• Persons with chronic medical illness or psychological disorders 

 But in the end,

CDC | Disaster Mental Health

Disaster Victims Identification

In case of mass casualty incident, it means a lot of dead body with unknown identity. Since situation is worse when the incident occurs causing the dead body to unable to be recognized and some of the body may be mutilated and it is impossible to find any personal identification on that body. Interpol has set a guide on how to identify disaster victim. Disaster Victim Identification (DVI) team consist of several victim identification unit with  specific duties and responsibilities.

• Recovery and Evidence Collection Team - The Recovery and Evidence Collection Team is responsible for the recovery of bodies at the disaster site and the collection and preservation of evidence and property at the site as well as the personal effects of victims within the extended area around the disaster site.
• Ante Mortem Team - The AM Team collects ante mortem data required for the identification of victims, prepares corresponding missing‐persons files and notifies the relevant authorities regarding completed identifications. 
• Post Mortem Team - The PM Team collects all relevant dental medical and forensic data obtained from the bodies of deceased victims for the purpose of identifying said victims. The team consists of experts in the fields of fingerprint analysis, forensic pathology, forensic odontology and DNA analysis. 
• Reconciliation Team - The Reconciliation Team is responsible for matching AM and PM data records, which ultimately leads to victim identification. In cases in which matches are identified, the Reconciliation Team submits the corresponding documents to the Identification Conference for review and final decision. 
• Care and Counselling Team - The Care and Counselling Team provides medical and psychological care and counselling for personnel in the Recovery, Evidence collection and Victim Identification unit. The team is also the point of contact for relatives of disaster victims within the context of family assistance. The team receives professional support for this difficult work from physicians and trained psychologists. 
• Identification Board - The Identification Board is a group of experts which meets at regular intervals to discuss and verify proposals submitted by the Analysis/Reconciliation Team. The Board makes final decisions regarding the identification of given victims and certifies these decisions on the DVI form.

According to the DVI procedure of Interpol, there are five steps to manage the dead victims of disaster. All the DVI team will be involve in the steps.

1. At the scene of incident
2. Collecting post mortem data
3. Collecting ante mortem data
4. Comparison of ante mortem and post mortem data (Reconsiliation)
5. Identification

At the scene of incident, the recover and evidence collection team will collect the body and make a skectch and photograph the location of body is found. They also need to recover all belonging/goods that surround the dead body and all evidences need to be sent together to the post mortem team for further examination. As the body arrive in the hospital, ante mortem and post mortem data is usually collected parallelly as both data will be needed in the next  reconsilation process. Data collected in this step can be primary or secondary from the body and will be used to identify that victim. As the end result of this whole process, a victim can be identified or not identified with several degree of certainty; possible, indeterminate or inconclusive and positive identification. This degree of certainty is in regard to the data that is being used to identify the patient as DNA comparison, dental record and fingerprint as the highest identification certainty.

INTERPOL Disaster Victims Identification Guide

Disaster and Disaster Management

The picture above is a conceptual framework of a disaster and disaster management with left part of it is the process of a disaster to occur and right part is the disaster management. As we know, disaster can be categorized to man made and natural disaster, and both type of the disaster events can be explain following this disaster framework. HAZARD is something that contents energy, so it could be an airplane or a volcano. At one time, something that content that much energy, must has a probability that some bad could happen, this is what is known as RISK. Thus realization of the hazard, i.e. volcano eruption is the event. Not a disaster yet, because certain things a required in order an event to be classify as a disaster. When an event comes into contact with those who has the vulnerabilities, this is the IMPACT of that event, and a negative result from an impact of an event resulting in damages. Be the DAMAGE is in the sense of social function, loss of life or property it still just an event circumstances. When the local government of where the event has occurred demand the needs of external aid for recovery, then it will finally be qualified as a DISASTER.

As you can see, the framework appears as a process, but in fact, it is actually an endless loop of event. Therefore the disaster management must be work to cut off or to end even this loop. The first steps of a disaster management is to prevent it from happening. PREVENTION is done to reduce the possibility of a hazard from going wrong and realization of its hazard. This mainly only possible in preventing man made disaster as we can only reduce and prevent the hazard of airplane and not a volcano. For example, we can design a plane with a better aviation system thus reducing the hazard. MITIGATION on the other hand, i usually used to minimize the after effect of an event. When early warning of an event already being confirm, here disaster management is the preparation to come face to face with the event. PREPAREDNESS embodies all plans that being done before the event occurs including evacuation plan, early detecting warning system and so on. During the disaster period, RESILIENCE take place in disaster management. This include the initiation of medical response, search and rescue team and initiation of rapid response team. In the evacuation camp, two terms is important reflecting the success of disaster logistic system; absorbing capacity and buffering capacity. Absorbing capacity is the capacity of the camp or hospital to receive the number of victims and buffering capacity the amount of inventories that was stored to be used disaster emergency situation. Disaster management for post disaster is the RECOVERY and DEVELOPMENT of the all the damages caused by its impact.

S. Triage. A. R. T.

"The bad artists imitate, the great artists steal." - Pablo Picasso H. Semat

Triage is a procedure of sorting of patients to priority-based category for transport and treatment according to degree of injury severity and medical emergency, in regard of first aid ABC system procedure (in field or hospital). Triaging includes selecting system in scene of accident by the responder and evacuating/transporting patients to the hospital or other health care facilities. For patient identification purposes, easiest way is by using colored-coded Triage Tag and the priority of patient management in triage are as follows:

• Highest Priority/Immediate/Class 1 (RED) : Emergency and life threatening patient (immediate care and life threatening)
• High Priority/Delayed/Class 2 (YELLOW) : Moderate and emergency patient (urgent care and can be delayed up to 1 hour)
• Immediate Priority/Minor/Class 3 (GREEN) : Emergency not life threatening, life threatening not emergency and not emergency and not life threatening (delayed care and can be delayed up to 3 hours)
• Last Priority/Class 4 (BLACK) : Probable death and patient with signs of death (victim is dead and no care required)

START on the other hand stands for Simple Triage and Rapid Treatment/Transport which is a modified triage commonly used in managing Multiple/Mass Casualty Incident (MCI). This system is done by the help personnel in 60 seconds or less for each patient and encompasses respiration, circulation and mental status examination. START system divides victims to 4 priorities exactly as in conventional triage with some modification as less time required to perform triage on mass victims.

• Immediate/Highest (RED)
• ventilation is present after airway is secured, or breathing is more the 30x/min
• capillary refill/filling more than 2 seconds
• unable to follow simple command
• Delayed/High (YELLOW)
• patient can't be categorized in immediate or minor
• Minor (GREEN)
• separated from the victims in the beginning of triage operation and usually known as "walking wounded"

Triage Tag is usually filled and done during the transport of victim to the hospital. Pay attention to details of;

1. time arriving to the scene of incident
2. date of incident
3. name (if conscious and coherent)
4. address
5. other important infomations
6. help personnel indentity
7. identification of traumatic patient (with photo)
8. vital sign and time of examination
9. record usage of IV drugs and other drug (advance life support)
10. place the tag on the cloth or on other part of easy to be noticed

 and examination of 3, 4, 5 can be postponed and completed in awaiting the transport team to be arrived.

Ref: Buku Panduan Pelatihan Basic Life Support TBMM FKUGM

Code of Professional Conduct

Doctors are bound to work professionally and becoming the leading in health care profession. Being a doctor is a highly paid profession which also demanded a high level of professionalism. This statement is seems recursive for most doctors bur this kind of lame platitude is needed to really remind us that we carry a heavy burden on our shoulder. Need I to remind:

The International Code of Medical Ethics (Excerpts)

"At a time of being admitted as a member of the Medical Profession:
I solemnly pledge myself to consecrate my life to the service of humanity:
I will practice my profession with conscience and dignity;
The health of my patient will be my first consideration;
I will maintain by all means in my power, the honour and noble traditions of the medical profession;
I will not permit considerations of religions, nationality, race, party politics or social standing to intervene between my duty and patients.
I will maintain the utmost respect for human life from its beginning even under threat, and I will not use my medical knowledge contrary to the laws of humanity."

The Declaration of Geneva (Excerpts)

I solemnly pledge myself to consecrate my life to the service of humanity.
I will practice my profession with conscience and dignity.
The health of my patient will be my first consideration.
I will respect the secrets which are confided in me.

General Medical Council (GMC) of UK had used several terms to describe the medical professional in action and they come out with Good Medical Practice as a principles and values as guidance which is addressed to General Practioners working in UK. Since Malaysia adapted their health care system mainly based on their former colonist British system, Malaysian Medical Council (MMC) has also set 10 principles for Malaysian doctor in defining a good medical practice. According to their published article about Duties of a Doctor, Good Medical Practice are:

The Ten Golden Rules of Good Medical Practice

1. Practise with Kindness, Ethics and Honesty.
2. Upgrade Professional Knowledge and Clinical Skills.
3. Maintain good Patient Records.
4. Maintain good Communication with Patients and Relatives.
5. Maintain Doctor-Patient Confidentiality.
6. Allow Second Opinion and Referral to Colleagues.
7. Maintain good Working Relationship With Colleagues.
8. Be conscious of Cost of Healthcare.
9. Avoid Publicity, Self-promotion and Abuse of Position.
10. Be a Partner in promoting Global Health.

Code of professional conduct are embodied in various Codes of Ethics which vary in detail from country to country but all place first and foremost the health and welfare of the individual and the family under the care of a practitioner. The MMC endorses the International Code of Medical Ethics and Declaration of Geneva which embodies these ideals, thus underpinning the Code of Ethics are statutes which make it an offence punishable under the law of the country to transgress certain outer limits of the expected norms of professional conduct. These minimum standards of conduct are assessed by their peers in the profession, assembled as the MMC established under the Medical Act 1971. Breaches of these minimum standards are referred to as 'infamous conduct in a professional respect' or 'serious professional misconduct'. This Code of Professional Conduct can be downloaded from MMC websites and the pdf file contain the definition of 'infamous conduct in professional respect', form of infamous conduct and disciplinary procedure to the convicted doctor.

GRID

"Flee fornication. Every sin that a man doeth is without the body; but he that committeth fornication sinneth against his own body." - 1 Corinthians 6:18 (King James Version)

In 1980, there was an increase of the occurrence of Kaposi's Sarcoma and fungal pneumonia among gay people in major cities in US, and since these diseases are common among immuno-compromise patients, they (doctors) named the disease as Gay Related Immune Deficiency (GRID). The name itself caused a major chaos among religion community, many preachers used this passage (1 Corinthians 6:18) condemning gay people and their lifestyle stating that this disease is the wrath from the Creator. But now we know better, for whatever reason that GRID a gay disease from God actually can  also infects straight people (how come?). Not until 1982 a proper name for this abomination was proposed; Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS) and the probable cause of this disease had discovered, a retrovirus which now commonly known as Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV). This picture below is 10 facts on HIV/AIDS that we should all know from WHO website.

When discussing about HIV/AIDS, there's not much that i know about. One program i know that is implemented in Indonesia called Prevention of Mother-to-Child Transmission (PMTCT) which is very important in preventing HIV/AIDS pandemic situation. I remember when browsing about PMTCT in the net, there's even people asking regarding how-about a child can get HIV, since s/he is not having sex at all. This really shows that there's people that are still ignorance bout this and the awareness about knowledge about HIV/AIDS vertical transmission is still minimum. In fact, it's a common myth and believe that HIV women can't get pregnant, and they will die young. This myth is a total bullshit and I believe that not all of us know the fact that a HIV positive woman can get up to 98% of chance in having a completely health child. True story!! I'm not bullshitting you some more. Mother to child transmission risk can be reduced to 2% with 3 essential steps:

• Antiretroviral administration
• elective caesrean section
• non-breast feeding

As a conclusion, I encourage we all to support World AIDS Day campaign on December 1st of every year to increase the community awareness and showing that we care and want to help preventing and curing this disease, HIV and AIDS. In contrast to pink ribbon used in breast cancer awareness campaign, World AIDS Day uses red ribbons as a symbol that we are aware of HIV/AIDS health burden. Here is a short video ads regarding this campaign and this year 2010 themes of World AIDS Day : Universal Access and Human Rights

Shed me some light...

 

Since I haven’t enrolled in any lectures regarding this topic, I really don’t know what to write in this entry, hence the title: shed me some light. I would like to discuss about two organizations that are responsible in monitoring and making the enquiry about the health surveillance.

 One surveillance system is under the well-known health organization; WHO, to be specific, the department of communicable disease and surveillance response (CSR). This department; CSR have an integrated global and alert system for any public health emergency in case of new emergence diseases or even the current health problems in the world population. This system is called as Global Alert and Response or in short GAR have several core functions which basically functions as to increase readiness and preparedness in facing an epidemic or pandemic situation by strengthening the biorisk reduction and the global operational platform to support outbreak response. In order to achieve the missions of GAR, CSR also created a global network of institutions; Global Outbreak Alert andResponse Network (GOARN) which act as the outreach programme for GAR to cover the world’s population. The video above is a short clip from the WHO webpage explaining about the aims of GROAN network formation. GAR covers a wide range of diseases listed from Anthrax to Yellow fever but this list is growing as new emergence disease occurs around the world

Second organization that can involve in the health surveillance monitoring system is from ex-US World War II Malaria commission which is founded by Rockefeller Foundation. Nowadays, with the name of Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), it also has some sort of surveillance system. Under health and safety topics, there’s Emergency Preparedness and Response subtopic which covers several specific hazards and since this organization has a military root, it also focus on bioterrorism, chemical and radiation emergencies and any mass casualty caused by explosions or blasts. However, CDC also takes interest in recent outbreaks and incidents. CDC also provide some guideline for every human force that can be involved in any emergency situation including guidelines for health care facilities in preparation and planning in adapting guidance for health care professional in facing disasters, pandemic, bioterrorism and so on.

As a whole, from these two organizations which are responsible to perform the health surveillance, it’s also important that all health care professional take part in the network of recording and reporting system so that all health incidents can be monitored and in case any of future occurrence of the same incident, it can be prevented and if unsuccessful we can at least prepared and ready for it.

Back to Basics

Merriam-Webster Open Dictionary

sur·veil·lance \sər-ˈvā-lən(t)s also -ˈvāl-yən(t)s or -ˈvā-ən(t)s\ 

noun 

Definition

: Close watch kept over someone or something (as by a detective); also : supervision

Examples

Government surveillance of suspected terrorists

The bank robbery was recorded by surveillance video cameras.

dis·ease \di-ˈzēz\ 

noun

Definition

1.      obsolete : trouble

2.      : a condition of the living animal or plant body or of one of its parts that impairs normal functioning and is typically manifested by distinguishing signs and symptoms : sickness, malady

3.      : a harmful development (as in a social institution)

— dis·eased adjective

Examples

He suffers from a rare genetic disease.

A disease of the mind

Thousands die of heart disease each year.

Medical Definition

: an impairment of the normal state of the living animal or plant body or one of its parts that interrupts or modifies the performance of the vital functions, is typically manifested by distinguishing signs and symptoms, and is a response to environmental factors (as malnutrition, industrial hazards, or climate), to specific infective agents (as worms, bacteria, or viruses), to inherent defects of the organism (as genetic anomalies), or to combinations of these factors : sickness, illness—called also morbus; compare health  

—dis·eased adjective

com·mu·ni·ca·ble \kə-ˈmyü-ni-kə-bəl\

adj

Definition 

1. capable of being communicated : transmittable <communicable diseases>
2. : communicative <prove myself a gentleman, by being … virtuous and communicable — Izaac Walton>

— com·mu·ni·ca·bil·i·ty noun

— com·mu·ni·ca·ble·ness noun

— com·mu·ni·ca·bly adverb

Examples

1. <communicable diseases that are usually transmitted sexually>

Related

Synonyms: catching, contagious, pestilent, transmissible, transmittable

Antonyms: noncommunicable

Medical Definition

: capable of being transmitted from person to person, animal to animal, animal to human, or human to animal : transmissible

—com·mu·ni·ca·bil·i·ty noun, plural com·mu·ni·ca·bil·i·ties

non·com·mu·ni·ca·ble \-kə-ˈmyü-ni-kə-bəl\

adj

Definition

: Not capable of being communicated; specifically : not transmissible by direct contact <a noncommunicable disease>

communicable disease

noun

Definition

: An infectious disease transmissible (as from person to person) by direct contact with an affected individual or the individual's discharges or by indirect means (as by a vector)—compare contagious disease

out·break \ˈau̇t-ˌbrāk\

noun

Definition

1.      a : a sudden or violent increase in activity or currency <the outbreak of war> b : a sudden rise in the incidence of a disease <an outbreak of measles> c : a sudden increase in numbers of a harmful organism and especially an insect within a particular area <an outbreak of locusts>

2.      : insurrection, revolt

Examples

<There was an immediate outbreak of paper shuffling and a pretense of work when the supervisor passed through the room>

<The government quelled the outbreak with ruthless efficiency>

en·dem·ic \en-ˈdem-ik, in-\

adj

Definition

: Restricted or peculiar to a locality or region <endemic diseases> <an endemic species>—compare epidemic , sporadic

—en·dem·i·cal·ly adverb

noun

Definition

1.      : an endemic disease or an instance of its occurrence

2.      : an endemic organism

spo·rad·ic \spə-ˈrad-ik\

adj

Definition

1.      : occurring occasionally, singly, or in scattered instances <sporadic diseases>—compare endemic, epidemic

2.      : arising or occurring randomly with no known cause <sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease>

—spo·rad·i·cal·ly adverb

ep·i·dem·ic \ˌep-ə-ˈdem-ik\

adj

Definition

1.      : affecting or tending to affect an atypically large number of individuals within a population, community, or region at the same time <typhoid was epidemic>—compare endemic, sporadic

2.      : of, relating to, or constituting an epidemic <coronary disease…has hit epidemic proportions—Herbert Ratner>

—ep·i·dem·i·cal·ly adverb

noun

Definition

1.      : an outbreak of epidemic disease

2.      : a natural population (as of insects) suddenly and greatly enlarge

pan·dem·ic \pan-ˈdem-ik\

adj

Definition

: occurring over a wide geographic area and affecting an exceptionally high proportion of the population <pandemic malaria> <pandemic influenza>

noun

Definition

: A pandemic outbreak of a disease

Quality Control

The previous post [Payment Mechanism] explains about the income source of a GP, and based on Forbes Magazine, health care professionals are among the highest paid occupation in US according to the data released by US Department of Labour in Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates, May 2009. This statistic puts surgeon as the highest paid occupation with anesthesiologist in the second notch of the list. With this condition, how the health system can manage the quality of care given to the patient by their doctors?

For this, several country have take some action in manipulating the GP salary so that GP performance quality is maintain to its maximum. UK is a country which pay their GP by monthly salary, but there is a new system called quality incentive which will be paid to the contracted GP according to the pay-for-performance mechanisms. In a paper written by Peter C. Smith and Nick York entitle Quality Incentive: The Case of UK General Practitioners stated that traditionally  GP income come from a mix of remuneration methods, including fee-for-service, capitation, salary, and capital and information technology (IT) but starting in April 2004 quality incentive will contribute up to 13% of the UK GP's income. The new incentive scheme uses 146 indicators of quality across seven areas of practice from clinical quality, practice organization to patient experience. UK government trying to accomplish a better quality control with better health status result at the patient's end.

Other than that, insurance company also can take action in maintaining the health care quality by putting a guideline to their contracted GP to perform clinical care accordingly and does not perform unnecessary procedure to the patient. This is called manage care and each insurance company has their own group of elite doctors in manage care which will assess the care given to that company's policyholder. Insurance company usually also give a list of essential drugs which can be prescribed to patient covered by that company. here it will help the patient from receiving unnecessary expensive drug where as cheaper yet same efficacy is available in the market.

Lastly, some hospital has their own committee that perform clinical audit to ensure that clinical care is done according to the latest evidence-based medicine and patient health care is handled correctly. This committee usually represented by the senior doctors in that practice. They are responsible to set the standard and collect the data from the current patient management in that practice, so that they can improve which area that need to be improved.

Payment Mechanism

All of us need and love money, it is essential and inevitable for living. That is why this blog is discussing about money yet again. First and foremost payment mechanism for a General Practitioner (GP) is monthly salary paid by the employers to the employees. Both public and private frequently used this same method to pay their employee and the only different is the total of renumeration earned by the GPs. Malaysia and Indonesia both pay their GP with salary, from the tax revenue, but the total income of GP in both country can widely vary. Indonesia GPs can earn unlimited allowance by working simultaneously in the private sectors, with limit of 3 different hospital allowed at a time. In contrary, Malaysia have limited allowances which mostly paid by the government to cover and compensate all the living expenditures and workload of a GP in Malaysia.  According to Suruhanjaya Perkhidmatan Awam (SPA) in Malaysia, the initial salary for a fresh graduated GP started from MYR 2458.39 and when sum up with all the allowances around give a total of MYR 4058.39 per month. This payment does not include the payment from the reimbursement for on call allowance and locum salary. From the news paper cut i read, on call allowance is at the rate of MYR150 per night and locum at the rate of MYR80 per hour.

Salary can be based on the GP contract with the employer, in this case; government because some countries use semi-negotiable salary to solve the "brain drain" of the GP to the big cities, private sector, and even overseas because of better renumeration and better living conditions. In Indonesia, semi-negotiable salary is used to attract more GP to work at the rural areas so they have an equal distribution of GP across the country. The payment is based on the degree of difficulty and rurality of the area. Some payment of salary is based on the capitation mechanism. The payment given to the GP is proportional to the amount of people under the responsibility of the GP, the more patients register under that GP, the more money that will be paid to that GP. This capitation payment can be used both government salary or payment reimbursement from health insurance for privileged GP.

Other payment mechanism to the GP is from the fee-for-service mechanism paid by the patient from out of pocket or from the insurance claims for medical services. Most people believe that this is the best way to maintain the quality of health care given by the GP because the amount of money they receive is totally depend on their patient satisfaction. It is just natural that a persons will try to give their best effort in delivering health care so that their patient pay their more. Happy patient means more money. There's another payment which is fundamentally derived from fee-for-service payment which is called as pay-for-performance (aka "P4P" or “value-based purchasing"). This payment mechanism gives incentive to the GP if there do well in treating their patient and preventive measures with a pre-established criteria and health indicators targets.

Moolah!!!

This is something that everyone crave for, including me.

Even health system craves for this.

We need this preferably in huge amount.

This is not a slang used by Malaysian to describe the sound of cows (moo lah).

We can rule the world with it, even cows.

Few years ago, a 2007 documentary film entitle Sicko by American filmmaker Micheal Moore was premiered which in investigate the health care system in US, focusing on its health insurance and the pharmaceutical industry. This movie really is an eye-opening documentary revealing about the truth condition of US health care, and basically the movie is trying to pursue a vision so that universal health care can be implemented in US. In US, moolah for health care comes from the health insurances. Most of health insurance in US is a commercial health insurance; a for-profit which requires the policyholder to pay premium to the insurance company. If you are not cover by any sort of health insurance, this is your only option. Since this is a for-profit health insurance, again, the only goal is to drain your moolah. Some even try to maintain the denial rate for medical claims because any claim is referred to as a medical loss.

Other type of health insurance is the non for-profit health insurance/social health insurance. This is what currently implemented in Indonesia. This type of health insurance is sometimes called as single-payer health insurance because the moolah paid to this insurance comes from the tax revenue. Social insurance can be public or private company; public company run by government paid by the government and private company paid by government but run by a non for-profit organization. However, most countries encourage their social insurance to have commercial insurance as well for those whom not covered by the social insurance. In this case, the premium will be paid by the policyholders themselves.

Moreover, most of the best health care systems ranked by WHO in their issue of The World Health Report 2000, Health System : Improving Performance use taxation as the source of moolah in health care. Allocation of taxation revenue moolah in the health care is widely used in Europe such as UK and France and Asia including Malaysia. UK and France a developed country, they are drowning by taxed paid by their citizen, therefore it is easier to allocate more money in health care and even educational fee. In Malaysia, health care system is operating in a two-tier health care; public and private sector. Moolah from tax revenue is only allocated to the public sector hospitals and private sector will earn their moolah from fee-for-service (out of pocket) and commercial insurance payments for health care services.

Moolah   =  Money

"Medicine is a business"

I read somewhere in the net where a German physician stating that, in his own words; "Medizin ist ein Geschäft". In plain English, it means that medicine is where a lot of money is and can be made or simply put medicine is a business. Part of me also believe that medicine is some sort of business where medicine can be seen in this business homologous:

Medicine Vs Business

Health system/governance <-> Company

Providers/care giver <-> Worker/human resources

Health care services/drug <-> Products/sales

Financing <-> Money

From this point of view, we actually can medicine can really works as a money with money oriented goal. If all health system in this world operate in such business-oriented mechanism, it will definitely will eliminate all of the true objectives[Tour d'horizon] of health system.  All that matters in business, is money, money and money. All health care services will be based on fee-for-service trade, which will generate even more money. Even in some conspiracy theory think that US are actually withholding cure for cancer to earn money from the pharmaceutical sales of chemotherapy which is used comprehensively in the treatment of most of cancers. Business-oriented health care system jeopardizes all the community health needs and reduces services delivery quality.

Hence, a well-structured and organized health care system need to be governed so that the latter situations will never happened. For this, we need great leadership can lead and governed health care system to reach its aims. It does not matter if a country decides to use either centralized or decentralized health system governance. Both of them have their own pros and cons.

"Decentralization does not mean a lack of accountability in resource management, nor that central government should opt out of planning and monitoring. It should be designed to increase accountability and should give central government and ministries a new role, focusing on overall regulation and monitoring." - Page 91 of The World Health Report 2000, Health System : Improving Performance

Secondly, provider and care givers is also an important input toward definitive health system. Human resources trainings will produces high quality medical and non medical staffs which will define the quality and effectiveness of care services given to the patients. These highly trained and skilled care provider also need to be distributed equally to all regions in order to the delivery of care reaching out to the community. All these can be easily achieved by leadership and well-governance health system.

Lastly, money. Apparently money is not that evil after all, money can be our friend instead of foe if we treat it cautiously.  We need money to run all the policies and technologies needed to achieve our goal. Financial status of a health system greatly determine the smooth running of all that have been mentioned here.